Fishers Island Vacations from $662

Staff was friendly. Room was okay. Wouldn’t stay there again.

Room was very clean and aesthetically pleasing. The views from the property were amazing! Nice and spacious as well. Will book again when I come back to NY!

Fantastic location, beautiful rooms, immaculate condition and the most amazing views

For an old hotel, it has been significantly improved. I had a few issues. The hallways were dark and the carpeting somewhat worn. More significantly, our room was very small and the bathroom, even smaller. For $700 per night this was inappropriate. Restaurant breakfast was dramatically overpriced. Otherwise a pleasant stay in a superb location

Overall it was a great stay! Best part of the cottage was the bathroom with its deep big tub and walk in shower. But the room itself lacked visual appeal & some conveniences usually associated with booking a cottage which is more private and removed from the house. Could use more and better art in the room. I would also trade all the storage space for a mini fridge, tea kettle or coffee maker. Also the only full-size mirror is hidden far back in the bathroom which isn’t terrible but very inconvenient to check the outfit before heading out the door. It’s little odd things that just made it not feel like a luxury stay. And no one mentioned to us beforehand that the sauna, gym, pool area (even though in off season) was under renovation and not available to use. The restaurant was amazing though, room service was wonderful. And staff were adorable. But I don’t know if we would book again tbh.